This is Athena Cruz-Albrecht’s response to and analysis of Chapter 41 of Keywords for Disability Studies by David Mitchell and Sharon Snyder.
The Implications of Narrative Writing for Disability Studies: On Keywords for Disability Studies and Related Works
Summary:
Narratives, which have existed since the start of human communication, are productions of a story that represent how a society, either real or imagined, works. This idea has significant implications with regards to how people live and coexist together, in addition to how they view one another. In Chapter 41 “Narrative” of Keywords for Disability Studies, David Mitchell and Sharon Snyder examine the effects of narrative within disability studies, and provide reasoning for the benefits that diverse narratives will bring to both people with disabilities and the accommodating communities around them.
The cultural impact of disability narratives is evident in narrative histories from hundreds of years across vast civilizations. The majority of these narratives, and the ones with greatest influence, are viewed as “portent” (126). For example, in Babylon and Assyria, children born with a ‘deformity’ were believed to represent bad omens, such as poor harvest cycles or famine. But disabilities are not limited to congenital nor physical traits. Those with cognitive disabilities throughout history have also been ridiculed, oppressed, and ostracized, even by both their own parents. Many times in ancient civilizations the shame of having a ‘defective’ or ‘deformed’ child led many parents to abandon them, leaving them to die from the elements. As Mitchell and Snyder point out, even royalty has not been exempt from this social repudiation—in one of his plays, William Shakespeare paints the story of King Richard III (a real king who suffered from scoliosis), whose hunchbacked body “excludes him from participation in the amorous pursuits of England at peace” (127). These narrative histories play a significant role in the characterization and division of groups of people, and influence the subjective view of the role of disabled peoples in society.
In contrast to the conventional usage of disabled characters as representations of inner evil or vice, at times disabled people are portrayed as the most clever or wise of a group. The rationale for this is that their ‘foolish’ or ‘unusual’ bodies or minds exempt their words and ideas from being construed or elucidated. Because people are not taught to take disabled people seriously, they become the perfect figure for knowledge, either in a comical or ironic manner. For example, in medieval Europe, people with developmental disabilities or short figures performed as fools and jesters for the courts. These people could use their “marginal status to speak ‘truth to power’ and thereby invert the operations of the known world for their benefactors” (127). Similarly, in the short story “Diary of a Madman” by Lu Xun, a ‘deranged’ man goes through a psychotic period where he believes that the people around him are eating other humans, and that in fact everyone has been practicing cannibalism across the nation for four thousand years. In one emotionally-fueled speech to his neighbors and brother, the madman views the audience as devilish, distorted creatures with fangs and horrid smiles; in an internal monologue, he says of these immoral cannibals: “Some believed that the eating of men must go on because it was how things had always been. Others recognized it for the sin it was, and yet still they ate, terrified of exposure” (29). During the 20th century in China, the government began to perpetuate the ideology of nationalism; anyone who was ‘unfit’ for the country was a disgrace. This story—regarded as the first in modern Chinese literature as it is written in vernacular, not classical, Chinese—is an allegory for the hierarchy of Confucian tradition and the ‘cannibalism’ of the lower, undesired social classes. The madman is terrified of being eaten, but that is because he is already being slowly consumed by the hierarchical society around him. This character is the most wise, empathetic, moral, and reasonable character in the story, but is deemed a deranged fool; his words are used for gawking amusement, not social change. Because the madman is mentally disabled, he can preach the most revolutionary ideas, and yet it all falls on deaf ears. The sharp contrast between the madman and everyone else further amplifies Lu Xun’s ironic criticism of the Confucian civilization. Whilst disabilities in narratives, both historical and fictional, are often used as representation of moral or intellectual flaws in the characters themselves, disabled characters can also be so knowledgeable that they are virtually unintelligible to others; this can be used comical and allegorical purposes.
An important aspect to consider with these narratives, however, is the idea and assumption that people with disabilities must be cured. Mitchell and Snyder urge readers to recognize the ‘kill-or-cure’ plotlines that much of the twentieth century media and narrative utilizes; in these plots, disability is portrayed as a negative character trait that a character can be cured of if they struggle and try hard enough. This idea is very problematic because it reduces disabled people as inferior beings who must be fixed like an out-of-tune instrument. People with actual permanent disabilities are not necessarily defined by them; rather, it could be simply a small part of their identity, or no part at all. The idea that disabled people spend their lives waiting and fighting to be cured is quite unreasonable and unrealistic. Rather than ‘curing’ one small aspect of their lives, it is vital to recognize them as individuals with distinct traits and personalities, just like every other group of people. Lu Xun makes a point of this ‘kill-or-cure’ plot in “Diary of a Madman,” where the beginning of the short story begins with a reassurance that the madman has been ‘cured’ and is now awaiting an official government position. The irony in this is that the madman’s ‘insanity’ represented a defiance of the government and social ‘cannibalism’ from Confucian traditions, but now he is a part of the system and will work for the government. “Narrative” explains that the obstructive impact of the ‘kill-or-cure’ ideology leads to a lack of political involvement: “Particularly ignored are those exclusions that have become nearly synonymous with experiences of disability, including rampant unemployment, inaccessibility, […] homelessness and its parallel context of chronic institutionalization, and forms of segregated education” (128). By thinking of a disability as a disease to be cured, society will not feel responsibility for the social disenfranchisement and economic marginalization of disabled peoples.
It must be recognized, despite all of the damaging narratives of disability in the past, that an increasing number of people are actively engaging in narrative histories to learn about their portrayal of disabilities. In his narrative Operation Wandering Soul, Richard Powers describes the way in which orphaned disabled children in a hospital ward will change the endings of cultural myths to happy ones. For example, in one Hindi tale, the little boy Hirochi is left to die of exposure, but the children imagine that he sails away in his coffin and happily travels the world. Michell and Snyder themselves wrote Narrative Prosthesis: Disability and the Dependencies of Discourse specifically to disregard the idea that a disability is something to be cured, and rather focus on the diverse expressions of disability throughout the centuries in literature and film which “parallel disability’s commonality across human communities” (129). Historical narratives can limit society’s perception of disability, but as narrative prosthesis emphasizes, reimagining everything from folk and fairy tales to Shakespeare’s Richard III and Melville’s Moby Dick is crucial to examining the characteristics and pervasiveness of disability narratives. This in turn, will make society more accepting and beneficial narratives more accessible to disabled and other marginalized peoples.
Questions / Reactions:
My reaction to this specific chapter “Narrative” of Keywords for Disability Studies was very positive: I felt enlightened and fascinated as if a whole new perspective was opened up for me. I particularly enjoyed reading it subsequent to “Diary of a Madman” because it made me think more deeply about why Lu Xun used a mental disability as a metaphor and the implications of that. Additionally, although Beethoven’s work is not quite a narrative, the fact that critics reacted to his later work with either astonishment at his genius because of his deafness or condemnation of his work because of his deafness speaks to the need of people to sometimes create false narratives. As Robin Wallace, the author of Hearing Beethoven, proclaims, “what sets the late works off, then, is that they have always been understood through the prism of deafness, their faults and virtues alike attributed to the fact that the man who wrote them could not hear” (73).
It begs the question, is a disability, even to a composer, necessarily an impediment? This in turn leads to a more broader question of what disability truly is, for everyone is ‘unable’ to do something. Is my inability to play the piano or read sheet music any less of a ‘disability’ than Beethoven’s inability to hear at the end of his life? How can the false narratives of ‘disability’ be overcome and dismantled from society? Furthermore, how can we use disability narrative analyses to better understand the lives and perspectives of those who include ‘disability’ as a part of their identity? These works have covered a portion of these answers, but I believe we will be searching for the rest of them far into the future.