This is Athena Cruz-Albrecht’s response to and analysis of “Paul Wittgenstein and the Performance of Disability” by Blake Howe.
Playing Disability, Not Music: On “Paul Wittgenstein and the Performance Of Disability” by Blake Howe
Summary:
The idea of a performance entails entertainment of some sort, whether that be from a production or simply a display of something unusual. In “Paul Wittgenstein and the Performance Of Disability,” Blake Howe, a professor of musicology at Louisiana State University, discusses the problematic characterization of the twentieth century pianist Paul Wittgenstein. Wittgenstein served a soldier in World War I and his right arm was amputated after being shot. Wittgenstein continued with his musical career and yet nearly all the narrative treatments of his disability included the following prejudiced tropes: 1) that Wittgenstein’s success was a heroic display of overcoming his disability, and 2) that his performances can most certainly ‘pass’ as a non-disabled pianist’s playing. These tropes, as a part of an overall focus on Wittgenstein’s disability rather than his music, highlight the obsession of onlookers to rationalize the abilities of ‘abnormal’ people and the subsequent need for those with disabilities to modify and adapt their playing to better suit the classical standard of a ‘perfect’ performance.
The perceptions of Wittgenstein during his life varied greatly depending on who was speaking. On the one hand, people were skeptical of Wittgenstein’s decision to continue playing piano after he was wounded in war. His own sister wrote that “he insists on doing what really cannot be done. It is “eine Vergewaltigung” (136). ‘Vergewaltigung’ is translated as ‘rape’ but has a connotation of violating something; in this case, Wittgenstein is violating the rules of classical music and of his own body. On the other hand, Wittgenstein also received overly enthusiastic and excited reviews. Rather than being supportive, these reviews were insincere and stemmed from the same prejudice that a pianist with a disability cannot attain the same standard of musical talent as a non-disabled pianist. Although reviews of Wittgenstein’s recordings often focus on the mistakes he made, the review of his live performances were overwhelmingly positive. This distinction is significant–it proves the need for critics to consider his disability before his music, but only when they see him perform in person. These two views of condensation and insincerity create a continual conflict between Wittgenstein’s performance and his body, representing “an embodied battle of ability versus disability, triumphant music versus pitiable appearance, left arm versus absent right” (140). Rather than viewing Wittgenstein’s body as a unique difference that can, but does not necessarily, affect his playing, critics and audience alike feel the need to characterize his disability as a deficiency, an obstacle to their perception of what a real pianist is.
The first highly prevalent trope in the narratives of Wittgenstein’s performance is the idea of him overcoming the terrible predicament of losing an arm as a pianist. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch wrote that Wittgenstein is renowned for having the “indomitable courage that turned misfortune into good fortune,” which even suggests that it was luck which allowed him to play after losing his arm. The Neue Freie Presse wrote that Wittgenstein’s playing does “not betray the artists’ melancholy at no longer possessing a right hand, rather they express his triumph at being able to bear his loss so well” (140). These characterizations of Wittgenstein’s performance as a courageous victory after his initial defeat (that is, becoming ‘disabled’) places Wittgenstein once again in a battle against his own body. The audience is unable to realize the source of Wittgenstein’s disability, which comes more from the constructions of normalcy within classical music than from his own bodily abilities and limitations.
The second and more evidently insulting trope used in narratives of Wittgenstein is the idea that he can ‘pass’ as a nondisabled pianist. The idea of ‘passing’ is the concealment of disability in a performance. These narratives show exaggerated amazement and perplexity at Wittgenstein’s ability to ‘sound nondisabled’–that is, to sound as if he is playing with two hands. Critics again rationalize the music that Wittgenstein was able to produce by saying it sounds like a ‘normal’ pianist’s playing. This idea of ‘passing’ can even morph into extraordinary hyperboles that exaggerate his ability to ridiculous proportions, such as a Cuban newspaper writing that Wittgenstein sounds like he is playing with four hands. Other reporters reassured readers that Wittgenstein’s performance was more than just a freak show. These include the Boston Evening Transcript writing that Wittgenstein is praised “not merely as a freak, but as a musician and virtuoso” and many others (142). These validations do not remove the idea of Wittgenstein as a freak in readers’ minds, but rather reinforce this characterization and generate a perception that Wittgenstein must be viewed as an abnormality before an artist. After an examination of the tropes used in narratives of Wittgenstein, it is clear to see that there is a dichotomy between his actual musical playing, which has often been critiqued negatively when it is in the form of a recording, and his disability as a part of his performance, either as a representation of his ‘heroic battle’ or his ability to ‘pass’ as a nondisabled pianist.
Questions / Reactions:
Wittgenstein had a significant impact on the number of pieces for one-handed pianists because he commissioned so many of them for his own performances. Before Wittgenstein, there was hardly any repertoire for one-handed pianists. This furthermore inspired and enabled pianists with disabilities in future generations to play professional compositions. It must be noted, however, that all of this was possible because of the economic status of Wittgenstein’s family. Musicians might have fairly equal opportunities to play, but the privilege of one person with a disability will affect others as well. Because of Wittgenstein’s financial freedom to commission so many pieces from very distinguished composers, both he and future pianists could perform without hardships in the amount of repertoire; but if Wittgenstein’s family was not in the socio-economic position to do so, their opportunities to perform would have been significantly hindered. It is important to to recognize the role of class in being able to ‘pay’ for society to accommodate one’s needs.
The reactions to Wittgenstein as an artist are distinct from other artists, such as Stevie Wonder and Evelyn Glennie, whose disabilities are less visually noticeable. This adds to the blatant distinctions between critiques of Wittgenstein’s live performances versus his recordings. In addition, the instruments of Stevie Wonder, Thomas Quasthoff, and Evelyn Glennie (that is, voice and percussion) are more easily molded around the artist’s specific needs. Pianos, on the other hand, have a standard of measurement and form; this means that it is rare, if not impossible, to encounter pianos made for the left hand. Because classical music has such a long history, its traditions are quite limiting against people who are not like the ‘typical’ musician. Furthermore, the very action of requisition accommodation is stigmatized in the classical world because it is viewed as an inconvenience and sometimes even as sacrilegious against the traditions of classical music.
The trope of viewing limitations of one’s body as a deficiency is apparent in almost all narratives about Wittgenstein. These narrations often characterize his career as a battle defeating his disability, and a symbol of heroic courage and victory; it is ironic that critics and audience feel the need to place this somewhat arbitrary war narrative on Wittgenstein when he was, in fact, in real battles during World War I. Rather than revered as a hero for fighting in the war, he is reduced to his appearance and the fact that he can (still!) play the piano after losing his right arm. Wittgenstein says that playing piano with one hand “demands double energy and work! The work consists partly in exaggerating the old skills, partly in modifying them” (154). When talking about normalcy and the hierarchy within classical music, it is interesting to note the difference between adapting to playing the piano with one hand versus overplaying. The former seems to be something that every musician has to deal with, as no two bodies are the same. For example, some people have small hands and either have to adapt to large keys or use a keyboard with smaller keys. But the latter seems to be specifically in order to ‘pass’ as a two-handed player to accommodate the listener, not the musician. This overworking of the single hand leads many people to criticize Wittgenstein’s playing as insensitive and unsubtle. It is ironic that when Wittgenstein tries to ‘pass’ as a nondisabled pianist, he is criticized for overplaying (or otherwise exaggerated into the role of a nondisabled pianist), but if he were to not overcompensate for his single hand, he would not have the success of a classical musician. It seems that no matter what Wittgenstein and other musicians do to appease society’s standards, one’s body and disabilities will almost always account to more than their musical, artistic, and creative abilities.